I teach low learners and am having a hard time with them understanding reading strategies. Is there any suggestions for mini-lessons and notes that would be SIMPLE for them to create a notebook as reference? Dee
Does anyone have any pros and cons to the push in pull out models for reading services? Currently we pull out and I think we will be encouraged to push in next year. What are the obstacles and benefits you see to pushing in? Thanks, Michelle
Pull out models: Pros: Quiet area in whic...See MoreOn 4/27/09, Michelle wrote: > Does anyone have any pros and cons to the push in pull out > models for reading services? Currently we pull out and I > think we will be encouraged to push in next year. What are > the obstacles and benefits you see to pushing in? > Thanks, > Michelle
Pull out models: Pros: Quiet area in which to work, may be easier to hold child's attention. Cons: Time lost in moving from room to room. Child loses out on what is going on in the classroom during his/her absence.
Push in models: Pros: More time on task when transition time is eliminated. Child continues to be part of class. Child may still absorb some of what is going on in classroom. Other children in class may absorb valuable parts of what reading teacher provides. It may be less obvious that child is receiving remedial services. Cons: Two teachers in the room may cause interference. Children may be more easily distracted. Requires some scheduling so teachers complement each other.
I'm a reading interventionist. I have 13 half-housr-long small groups daily. Some I push in; others are pull out. Here are some other thoughts.
Push in cons: Unless the classroom teacher has great control over what the students are doing who aren't in groups, it can be really noisy; even my high students "lost it" during testing week when half the class couldn't go to the reading computer lab as the usually do. Also, both teachers need soft voices so there isn't too much sound.
Organizing materials: I have to take a huge rolling cart with me so I have materials for each group; it is full of baskets and tubs with materials.
Sometimes you see teachers' faults, and I hate that. And they may see mine, lol.
Pull out cons: possible stigma, though our school has tons of kids going to different areas for reading all the time, so probably not a big deal. In fact, some kids keep asking, "When do I get to go with you?"
Time wasted in getting students.
Pros: Pull-outs, it is easier for me to have my materials accessible.
Push-in: see Grace's responses. Plus, I've learned a few things form being in a teacher's room.
dlSue, I worked with this program for three years and have mixed feelings about it. It's strengths are that many parts of it support the instruction going on in the classroom. Some of the weaknesses: It is canned and doesn't allow for creativity or flexibility if you follow it strictly. The amazing words are not the same as those presented in the cla...See MoreSue, I worked with this program for three years and have mixed feelings about it. It's strengths are that many parts of it support the instruction going on in the classroom. Some of the weaknesses: It is canned and doesn't allow for creativity or flexibility if you follow it strictly. The amazing words are not the same as those presented in the classroom. If you skip a week, or a large part of a week of instruction (which happened in the building I was working in due to state testing, etc.) then the assessment provided by the series doesn't align with instruction and you will not get an accurate reflection of how the child is progressing. I found the pace too quick for about half of the 6 students I was servicing. They needed to repeat certain skills but the building wouldn't allow me to stop, I had to keep pace with the classroom teacher who was also required to "move on" each week. The Scott Foresman rep told us that we were not to teach to mastery and that the built in spiral review would allow students to catch up. I did not find this to be true for many students. Are you planning to use it in isolation or with Reading Street?
CathyOn 4/29/09, dl wrote: > Sue, > I worked with this program for three years and have mixed > feelings about it. It's strengths are that many parts of it > support the instruction going on in the classroom. > Some of the weaknesses: It is canned and doesn't allow for > creativity or flexibility if you follow it strictly. The > ama...See MoreOn 4/29/09, dl wrote: > Sue, > I worked with this program for three years and have mixed > feelings about it. It's strengths are that many parts of it > support the instruction going on in the classroom. > Some of the weaknesses: It is canned and doesn't allow for > creativity or flexibility if you follow it strictly. The > amazing words are not the same as those presented in the > classroom. If you skip a week, or a large part of a week of > instruction (which happened in the building I was working in > due to state testing, etc.) then the assessment provided by > the series doesn't align with instruction and you will not > get an accurate reflection of how the child is progressing. > I found the pace too quick for about half of the 6 students I > was servicing. They needed to repeat certain skills but the > building wouldn't allow me to stop, I had to keep pace with > the classroom teacher who was also required to "move on" each > week. The Scott Foresman rep told us that we were not to > teach to mastery and that the built in spiral review would > allow students to catch up. I did not find this to be true > for many students. Are you planning to use it in isolation > or with Reading Street?
Plan on spending a minimum of 30 minutes each lesson, just with the lesson. If you want to include more independent practice or feel that the lesson will take longer than intended with your group of students look at 45-60 minutes. It should be fairly easy to reinforce many of their concepts as it's basically reading prefixes, suffixes, and vowel sounds, and putting them together to read fluently.
Good luck ~ Jenn
If you have students who DO need to move more slowly I would recommend SRA's Direct Instruction - Corrective Reading, Decoding (the Comprehension is also good, but VERY structured).
On 4/29/09, Lisa Lowery wrote: > I am looking for interventions for 4-6 graders. Has anyone > used the REWARDS method? If so, what success have you > experienced?
No: 20/10, Padmanaban Street, Sri Devi Nagar,kamaraj nagar Email ID : [email removed].
Objective: To be a part of a fast growing organization that recognizes and encourages my skills and abilities towards mutual growth.
Experience Summary: Around 8 Years of experience in sales, shop in charge and microprocessor maintenance.
Educational Qualification: Qualification Name of Institution Board of study Year of passing Diploma in Electronics and Communication Sri Ram Polytechnic State Board of Technical Education 2000 SSLC Penguin Matriculation School Matriculation 1997
Additional Qualification: Diploma in Computer Application (DCA)
Other Skills: „« MS Office Package, „« Telecommunication GSM, „« GPRS, „« Edge, „« Outlook Express, „« Billing System WINDSS, „« JDA, „« APEX
Work Experience 1: Name of the Organization : Mobile Store India Pvt. Ltd. (ESSAR) Period : 2006 ¡V Till date Designation : Manager ¡V Store.
Company Profile: Mobile store India Pvt. Ltd. is an Essar Global Limited (EGL) group company. EGL is a diversified business corporation with a balanced portfolio of assets straddling the manufacturing and services sectors: Steel, Energy, Power, Communication, Shipping & Logistics, and Construction.
Responsibilities: „« Take care of sales „« Shop operations „« Staff Management „« UPS power MICROPROCESSOR maintains through out Tamil Nadu in ESSAR mobile stores.
Work Experience 2: Name of the Organization :Univercell telecommunication India private ltd. Period : 2000 - 2006 Designation : Manager ¡VStore In charge. Responsibilities: „« Take care of sales „« Staff Management Personal Profile: Name : A. Rajesh Date of Birth : 07.07.1980 Marital status : Single Nationality : Indian
Declaration: I hereby declare that all the information given above is true to the best of my knowledge.
A.RAJESH
No: 20/10, Padmanaban Street, Sri Devi Nagar,kamaraj nagar Email ID : [email removed].
Objective: To be a part of a fast growing organization that recognizes and encourages my skills and abilities towards mutual growth.
Experience Summary: Around 8 Years of experience in sales, shop in charge and microprocessor maintenance.
Educational Qualification: Qualification Name of Institution Board of study Year of passing Diploma in Electronics and Communication Sri Ram Polytechnic State Board of Technical Education 2000 SSLC Penguin Matriculation School Matriculation 1997
Additional Qualification: Diploma in Computer Application (DCA)
Other Skills: „« MS Office Package, „« Telecommunication GSM, „« GPRS, „« Edge, „« Outlook Express, „« Billing System WINDSS, „« JDA, „« APEX
Work Experience 1: Name of the Organization : Mobile Store India Pvt. Ltd. (ESSAR) Period : 2006 ¡V Till date Designation : Manager ¡V Store.
Company Profile: Mobile store India Pvt. Ltd. is an Essar Global Limited (EGL) group company. EGL is a diversified business corporation with a balanced portfolio of assets straddling the manufacturing and services sectors: Steel, Energy, Power, Communication, Shipping & Logistics, and Construction.
Responsibilities: „« Take care of sales „« Shop operations „« Staff Management „« UPS power MICROPROCESSOR maintains through out Tamil Nadu in ESSAR mobile stores.
Work Experience 2: Name of the Organization :Univercell telecommunication India private ltd. Period : 2000 - 2006 Designation : Manager ¡VStore In charge. Responsibilities: „« Take care of sales „« Staff Management Personal Profile: Name : A. Rajesh Date of Birth : 07.07.1980 Marital status : Single Nationality : Indian
Declaration: I hereby declare that all the information given above is true to the best of my knowledge.
On 5/09/09, Cathy wrot...See MoreI'm sorry; I've not familiar with Spire. However, from the ABCD web site tehre is a link to join the Yahoo group - there are at least 2 people there I can think of who may have the answer - Michael Bend, the author of ABCD, and another woman who is also a special ed. teacher as well as a private tutor.
Jenn
On 5/09/09, Cathy wrote: > Jenn - can you (or someone else) speak to the differences between ABCD > and Spire? Thanks. Cathy > > On 5/07/09, Jenn wrote: >> I have the book and did use some of the lessons. However, I >> strongly suggest you take a look at another program that was based >> on Phonographix and incorporates the same philosophy, but is much >> more structured (lessons that you don't have to make, everything >> there for you between the student books and the teacher manuals.) >> It is called ABeCeDarian - the web site is [link removed];
I was trained in Phono-Graphix and tried it as designed with several students in a private reading practice. About the same time I started investigating The Spalding Method described in the book "The Writing Road to Reading" and found a lot of overlap between the two methods. Spalding seemed to address some weaknesses in Phono-Graphix and left less to chance, but it was too long and too sequential to use in the short time I had to work with my clients.
Eventually, I borrowed from both methods and combined them, and wrote a workbook that organized the result. That workbook has the decodable stories mentioned above. There are easy large print stories to be used immediately after a major vowel sound is covered and then longer more difficult stories to be used after the secondary lessons on that vowel sound have been completed. The stories were written so that a child following the curriculum should run into very few words that contain code not already covered.
I still feel that the basic code approach in Reading Reflex (Phono-Graphix) is superb and still use it exactly as I was trained when I run into a child who isn't blending simple words yet and doesn't know the sounds represented by the individual letters. But as soon as I get to advanced code work (the /ow/ sound, and digraphs such as "th", "sh" and "ch", I switch to my workbook for the rest of the phonics training. This takes them through 4-syllable decoding eventually.
To get a feel for the workbook, try going to the link at my website, OnTrack Reading, and download the free instruction manual for the workbook. It essentially describes exactly what I do as I go through the workbook page by page, as well as how to sequence the various phases of the program. When I used Phono-Graphix I used to get final code knowledge scores in the 70-80% range. I now routinely get 90% or better with a knowledge of a lot of the overlap options. For example, the average "graduating" 4th grader can tell me the three sounds he's learned for the letter "a" (/a/cat, /ae/table and /o/father) as well as the three sounds for the letter "i" (/i/hit, /ie/mind and /ee/ski). This didn't happen when I used Phono-Graphix as it was designed. It's a good method, better than most, but the combination of Spalding and Phono-Graphix is working much better for me.
If you use the link below, the instruction manual download is mentioned in the fourth paragraph from the end of the page. It's free.
I have a student that can sound out every letter in a word, but cannot blend it together. I am thinking it is a memory thing...he cannot hold more than one sound in his head at a time. Any suggestions? How about activities? He is in K.
As a Reading Specialist for o...See MoreOn 5/07/09, Heather wrote: > I have a student that can sound out every letter in a > word, but cannot blend it together. I am thinking it is a > memory thing...he cannot hold more than one sound in his > head at a time. Any suggestions? How about activities? He > is in K.
Dear Heather,
As a Reading Specialist for over 35 years, I have discovered that teaching children to blend sounds can lead to a bottleneck. The reason is that although they may finally learn to blend "controlled" sentences such as "Pat cat ran and ran" (after ingenious tactics, needed in some cases, employed by creative teachers) - alas, English is not a language that can be blended letter-by-letter. For example, try to "blend" a sentence such as, "You are my best friend" or for that matter try to "blend" any sentence in this or any other post on this site.
Nevertheless, if you are at a school that requires this method, you can get around it very easily this way. FIRST "tell" the student the word and THEN ask, "What sounds do you hear in this word from left to right?" and have them underline each sound as they pronounce it. It takes out all the strain and struggle because the word is known beforehand and they soon get the message and start doing it on their own.
I know I may get some flak on this - but it works like a charm.
Anyways, the key to your success (or frustration) will be how well you diagnose and differentiate instruction based upon the results of that diagnosis. I suggest that you download my freebie multiple choice reading and spelling assessments at [link removed]).
To get you planning in advance, you will certainly want to work on fluency development. Here is a nice article on how to differentiate fluency instruction within the classroom. It includes the intervention design and behavioral management component. [link removed]
Have fun! Don't hesitate to email me at [email removed].
Mark Pennington MA Reading Specialist On 5/15/09, New To Remedial Reading wrote: > I'll be teaching high school remedial reading next year in > an inclusion class using SRA Corrective Reading. I believe > the majority of my students will have IEPs. I don't know > the specific needs of my individual students yet, but I'm > seeking any advice you may have. I'm a little nervous > since I've only taught grade level English in the past. > I'Ve also been told many of my students will have behavior > issues (I understand that can come from being a high > school student who is reading far below level, or also > can be a part of a disability.) I'm looking for ideas on > structuring the class, what to expect, how to handle > behavior.
Hi! I am currently a high school English teacher who just got hired as a reading specialist for an intermediate school. Does anyone have any suggestions of "must-have" books or materials that may be helpful? I am looking for a "bible," so to speak, for the reading specialist. I'd appreciate any help you could offer. Thanks!!