I would highly suggest a subscription to Reading a-z.com- my 4th and 5th grade learning disabled students really enjoy the non fiction stories at their reading level very much. You download and print out the "book" and make multiple copies on the copy machine. There are so many great stories to pick from and each story has lesson plans, activities, and a comprehension quiz. The students can keep the book if they really like the story.
Also you can choose a novel that they are interested in and read a chapter or so a day to them- asking questions as you go along. Then plan activities( if possible) that go along with the story. We did something similar and after we read (meaning: listened to the teacher read aloud) 3 stories, the children each picked a novel they really liked and did cereal box book reports. We aslo did reading response logs this way, with teacher modeling the structure. The novel may be one that the regular ed students are reading in their class. This way your students have a commanality with their classmates.
I also have some books on tape and made copies of the story for each so we could follow along.
On 8/04/09, Linda wrote: > On 8/04/09, C. Darrimon wrote: >> I have a mild/moderate 4th and 5th grade SDC class. The >> problem I have is that most of my 4th and 5th grade >> students read at a 1st and 2nd grade reading level, but >> they get bored with the reading material availabe at that >> level. It's hard to keep these 4th and 5th graders >> interested when they are reading what they consider "baby >> books". High interest/low reading level books don't always >> go down to 1st and 2nd grade reading level. Any >> suggestions? > > > I would highly suggest a subscription to Reading a-z.com- my > 4th and 5th grade learning disabled students really enjoy the > non fiction stories at their reading level very much. You > download and print out the "book" and make multiple copies on > the copy machine. There are so many great stories to pick > from and each story has lesson plans, activities, and a > comprehension quiz. The students can keep the book if they > really like the story. > > Also you can choose a novel that they are interested in and > read a chapter or so a day to them- asking questions as you > go along. Then plan activities( if possible) that go along > with the story. We did something similar and after we read > (meaning: listened to the teacher read aloud) 3 stories, the > children each picked a novel they really liked and did cereal > box book reports. We aslo did reading response logs this way, > with teacher modeling the structure. The novel may be one that > the regular ed students are reading in their class. This way > your students have a commanality with their classmates. > > I also have some books on tape and made copies of the story > for each so we could follow along. > > It's a lot of work, but well worth it.
Has anyone used comic books or graphic novels to teach reading to below level readers? Any info or advice would be appreciated. I'm a middle school teacher.
JennyOn 8/12/09, LA 6 wrote: > Has anyone used comic books or graphic novels to teach > reading to below level readers? Any info or advice would be > appreciated. I'm a middle school teacher.
I've never used them to teach but the Bone series by Jeff Smith has hooked many a struggling reader in my 7th and 8th grade classess.
1. Teachers want to achieve this goal in the shortest amount of instructional time. 2. Teachers want diagnostic assessments that will pinpoint individual reading strengths and deficiencies. But, they don’t want assessments that will eat up excessive amounts of instructional time or cause mounds of paperwork. 3. Teachers don’t want to waste time by starting each learner from “scratch” with hours of repetitive practice. 4. They want the targeted resources to be able to teach students what the results of the diagnostic assessments indicate to be their clear weaknesses in the shortest amount of time possible. 5. To mix metaphors, teachers want program resources that will enable them to establish a clear game plan, but also ones which will allow them to deviate from that plan, according to the needs of their students. 6. Teachers want resources that won’t assume that they are reading specialists. However, they don’t want resources that treat them like script-reading robots. Teachers are fast learners. 7. Teachers want resources that they can grab and use, not resources that require lots of advance preparation. Teachers want to do a great job with their students and still maintain their sanity. 8. Teachers want reasonable class sizes that are conducive to effective remedial instruction. 9. Teachers understand that remedial readers frequently have behavioral problems; however, their behaviors can’t interfere with other students’ rights to learn. Administrators have to buy-in to this condition. 10. Teachers want to be able to integrate writing, grammar, and spelling instruction and include real reading in their remedial reading programs, not solely skill development.
On 9/12/09, Mark Pennington wrote: > You're welcome....See MoreAlso check out the Stieglitz Informal Reading Inventory. It is a very good tool to use to determine a student's reading levels, and goes quite deep into determining which reading cueing system the student uses )or doesn't use). I got my copy off of Amazon...it's been a godsend for me.
On 9/12/09, Mark Pennington wrote: > You're welcome. Time to get that one off my chest. Diagnostic and > formative data are the best weapons in our teacher arsenals to > fend off unworkable programs and student program placements that > just don't make sense. Diagnostic and formative data that > directly affect our instruction are what we need (and our > students).The summative data that affect administrator job > evaluations, such as the CST, et al, are much less valuable. > Check out my free reading, spelling, grammar-mechanics > whole-class diagnostic assessments at > [link removed].
(Who said you had to start from scratch? There is NO single reading program that works for all students but it sounds as if you've been made to use one single program with much repetitive practice. Wilson?)
And I'd ask you - exactly what targeted resources do you want me to purchase for you now that you've done the diagnostics?
I hear you on the reasonable class sizes and behavioral issues.
And how do you want to incorporate 'real reading' into your program? Fine, go for it and tell me what trade books you want me to purchase for you. > >. 8. Teachers want reasonable > class sizes that are conducive to effective remedial > instruction. 9. Teachers understand that remedial readers > frequently have behavioral problems; however, their > behaviors can’t interfere with other students’ rights to > learn. Administrators have to buy-in to this condition. 10. > Teachers want to be able to integrate writing, grammar, and > spelling instruction and include real reading in their > remedial reading programs, not solely skill development.
So my question is, do you have all books at a level open to a student and they get to choose the ones they want until all books at a level are complete? Or would it be a good idea to limit the books available to one or two at a time and require students to complete the listening, reading and passing the quiz before more are added? Maybe I am just overthinking it and maing RAZ-kids harder than it's meant to be, but I want them to be meaningfully engaged and accountable (and for their reading to improve). Thanks, Christine
Sped teacherI'm using Raz-Kids for the first time. I am afraid of the same thing hapening that you have described. Can you just select a few books in each level for the students? I have it set right now to have them move through the levels. I plan to have them all in the log at once and also be able to access them from home. We start this tomorrow so we shall ...See MoreI'm using Raz-Kids for the first time. I am afraid of the same thing hapening that you have described. Can you just select a few books in each level for the students? I have it set right now to have them move through the levels. I plan to have them all in the log at once and also be able to access them from home. We start this tomorrow so we shall see. On 8/22/09, Christine wrote: > I have a question for anyone who uses RAZ-kids. I have > found that some of my students don't use it as well as they > should. When I look at their reports it seems like they > really jump around from story to story and might take a > quiz 5 times and still only score 4/10 every time. I know > they are at the correct level, I just don't think they are > putting effort into it. These are 6th graders who are > several years below grade level. I use it while I work > with small groups so students are occupied, so it is hard > for me to monitor their time and attention on each story. > And my new group doesn't even know about the rocket feature > yet. I can just see them clicking through stories and > quizzes just to earn stars without even reading. > > So my question is, do you have all books at a level open to > a student and they get to choose the ones they want until > all books at a level are complete? Or would it be a good > idea to limit the books available to one or two at a time > and require students to complete the listening, reading and > passing the quiz before more are added? Maybe I am just > overthinking it and maing RAZ-kids harder than it's meant > to be, but I want them to be meaningfully engaged and > accountable (and for their reading to improve). > Thanks, > Christine
It can vary, but I would say most of a school year. I am just beginning the Wilon certification course and you have to do at least 60 hours of tutoring with a student. I am going to tutor 2 times a week for an hour each so it will take 30 weeks, not counting Christmas, spring break, etc.
This is my first year teaching remdial reading for 9th grade. I would like to intoduce some visual learning for their reading comprehension understanding, but I'm not sure how to approach it. Has anyone had any experience with this type of teaching. Thank you in advance for you help.
SIPPs is great but doesn't address comprehension...Read Naturally is another great one.
Check out [link removed].
Thanks.
On 9/10/09, Valecia wrote: > It doesn't sound as though many of you are fans of RtI, > but we are implementing it here in Colorado, and feel > useless without a strong curriculum for our SPED kids. > Does anyone have any ideas on a curriculum that teaches > all 5 components of reading for SPED kids? We have used > Wilson in the past and have not found it to be very > effective. Please help, any and all suggestions are > welcome? > > thanks
9/12/09, Elizabeth Chapin-Pinotti wrote: > We use do RtI in California as well. We use SRA Corrective > Reading and Reading Mastery. For small groups of young > students we use SRA Reading Tutor. > > SIPPs is great but doesn't address comprehension...Read > Naturally is another great one. > > Check out [link removed]
I teach in Australia and I haven't seen anything by that name. We have a list of 5 sentences for a test called Hearing and Recording Sounds in Words. They are marked out of 37. If this is what you are after they are in Marie's Book titled- "An Observation Survey." If you can't get a hold of it, let me know and I'll pass on the sentences.
My daughter just started 1st grade and brought home a book to read from school that was a level 16. She read it with very minimal problems. What is expected at this point in 1st grade?
On 8/27/10, Amy Kelley wrote: > On 9/15/09, Amy wrote: >> My daughter just started 1st grade and brought home a book >> to read from school that was a level 16. She read it with >> very minimal problems. What is expected at this point in >> 1st grade? > > Hello,my son has done the same thing.He is reading level 16 1 > week into first grade.I am wondering how things progress when > they are ahead of what there supposed to be reading.Any > response would be helpful.
If I had a first grader reading a 16, I would be t...See Moreat my school, the average 1st grader comes into 1st grade reading a DRA of a 4. By the end of 1st grade he/she should be at a 14 (although 16 is really what is best). To start 2nd grade, we look at a student reading at a 16 at the beginning of the year and a 24- 28 at the end of 2nd grade.
If I had a first grader reading a 16, I would be totally happy. But then I teach Title 1, and have first graders who are at level A- 1 even now in December.
Sara S.
On 10/22/10, Bump wrote: > I don't usually let them move on from level 11- 12+, until I > ensure that they have good comprehension of what they have read, > and can read it fluently with good phrasing and expression. I > had a group of readers that came into grade one last year, > level 24-25, that were the most fluent, lovely readers I have > ever heard, but they didn't understand a thing. So we basically > stayed at that same level throughout the year, working on > comprehension. There isn't much point on them going much beyond > that anyway, as the content becomes much more mature, and > contains things that I would not want my 6 year old reading. > > On 8/27/10, Amy Kelley wrote: >> On 9/15/09, Amy wrote: >>> My daughter just started 1st grade and brought home a book >>> to read from school that was a level 16. She read it with >>> very minimal problems. What is expected at this point in >>> 1st grade? >> >> Hello,my son has done the same thing.He is reading level 16 1 >> week into first grade.I am wondering how things progress when >> they are ahead of what there supposed to be reading.Any >> response would be helpful.