Do other teachers see this in the general ed...See MoreI am a special ed teacher and I have noticed that many of my students write capital Ps for all of their ps in their writing. I have been successful in correcting this with some students but I have one who is extremely resistant to any correction but especially this one. So I have two questions.
Do other teachers see this in the general education students?
If a student writes a capital P in the middle of a word on a spelling test do you count it as incorrect?
I always give a chance at the end of the test to correct this error, saying "Check your papers for any capital letters that don't belong, especially Ps."
And I'm sorry you didn't get some - maybe because I'm unfamiliar with this. I've never had students who uppercase their Ps. I have taught spec. ed - still do - and I've got bigger battles to fight than that but it's intruiging. I've got kids who reverse ps and qs and bs and ds and I've got one who capitalizes any word he thinks is important - no matter how often I tell him that's Not a rule... I've got another who underlines a word in her writing if she doesn't 'believe' in the word. She underlined 'witch' several times in her Halloween story.
It's an adventure. What happens when you ask this student - "Uh, John, you keep uppercasing your Ps. Why is that? Do you think P is more important than the other letters (the 'pee' in P might result in some giggles) But me, I'd really be curious as to what he's thinking if he's thinking at all. > Thanks
Does this student also write his lower case g's and j's slightly differently than you would expect even though they are both lower case? The circle of the g may be in the upper half of the line and the stem of the g above the bottom line. The j may not dip below the bottom line very much, if at all) Some students have trouble with letters that go below the bottom line because their perceptual skills are somewhat weak. I would not pay attention to it for a little while. In another couple of weeks, ask him if it's okay if you help him with this and pull him separately. Cut a strip of paper and draw dotted lines on it. Place the paper on a small wipe off board. Have him start on the dots and draw a stem so that it goes below the line. Then have him finish drawing the letter. Have him write several p's that way. Then have him use cool pens and paper (glitter pens, scratch paper that you have lined and dotted, etc.)write short words you dictate that begin with p's. Progress to words with p in the middle and then to words with p at the end. Then dictate phrases such as "the pal." You could also have him switch colors when he gets to the "p" in the word to raise his awareness. The switching of the colors works with capitalization and punctuation also.
You can motivate him by saying that you will be counting up all the p's in his writing and when he has a certain total, there's a reward. Think of rewards together and create a system so that it's possible for him to earn the first reward within a week. Reward ideas: lead a class game that you don't play often, snowball or popcorn treat. (I have a small snowball machine that I bring in.)
On 11/06/10, panther wrote: > I am a special ed teacher and I have noticed that many of > my students write capital Ps for all of their ps in their > writing. I have been successful in correcting this with > some students but I have one who is extremely resistant to > any correction but especially this one. So I have two > questions. > > Do other teachers see this in the general education > students? > > If a student writes a capital P in the middle of a word on > a spelling test do you count it as incorrect? > > I always give a chance at the end of the test to correct > this error, saying "Check your papers for any capital > letters that don't belong, especially Ps." > > I am looking forward to your responses. > Thanks
Are there any online resources or otherwise that prepare students for standardized tests where they are asked to ID the misspelled word out of a series of sentences? My kiddos are having a terrible time with this.
SherieThis is my first year using Words Their Way. I do several of the activities they describe in the books. On Mondays, I meet with each group, introduce the sort and have them go back to their desk and sort them again on their own. On Tuesdays, they pull out their cards, which we keep at their desks in ziplocks, and sort them again, then write them in...See MoreThis is my first year using Words Their Way. I do several of the activities they describe in the books. On Mondays, I meet with each group, introduce the sort and have them go back to their desk and sort them again on their own. On Tuesdays, they pull out their cards, which we keep at their desks in ziplocks, and sort them again, then write them in their notebooks. On Wednesdays, we do a blind sort. They meet with their partner (I assign partners ahead of time and they keep them for a few weeks), who reads the words aloud to them and they write them again in their notebooks (as a sort). Then they do the same for their partner. On Thursdays, when they finish their reading test and have independent reading time, they do a Word Hunt for words with the same patterns in their reading. They also keep this list in their notebooks. On Fridays, we have the test. I am planning on adding in a speed sort after Christmas where they use stopwatches to time themselves doing a sort (or a partner could time it). They do it twice to see if they can beat their time and get faster. I may alternate the speed sort with the blind sort each week on Wednesdays. My kids are doing very well with spelling and I am seeing much progress. I spend about 15 minutes a day on spelling. It is quick and easy, however, I have a small class and only 2 groups.
Hope this helps in some way. Let me know if you have any questions.
Sherie (3rd)
On 11/30/10, InterTeacher wrote: > Help! I am so lost in the logistics of the Words their Way > Program. I have four groups in my classroom - each group > arranged according to spelling skill/level. I had a > volunteer copy off the next 10 word sorts for each of the > groups. I start out fine, I give each group their sort, > then they spend 15 mins or so sorting, then write the sorts > in their word books, then the week goes on without going > back to the darn words, b/c I am not certain about where to > go from there! I want the kids working on the words each > day, but I also need to figure in time to work with the > small groups as well, and I'm not getting to it. What kinds > of activities should the kids be doing with the words on a > daily basis, and how do you organize your words their way > program???
I am a Wilson Language Teacher & a Special Education Teacher, with a Certification in Behavior Analysis. If you live in the New York area, specifically the city and/or the surrounding counties then please contact me via email for rates and approaches. Thank you! All the Best!
Well, they can't. I separate spelling out from writing actually... Students can write even if they can't spell and if they can't spell, it's better than it doesn't stop them from writing. For two reasons - their spelling usually improves with age - why wait for that? Why have them write only when they can spell?
And - I rarely write anything by hand anymore - who does?? I use Spellcheck and it tells me with a wavy red or green line that I haven't spelled something correctly.
I put up a word wall with commonly misspelled words and if I have time, I'll circle misspelled words in their paper and write the correctly spelled words above it. But - I require my students of almost all ages to type.
On 12/13/10, Sara wrote: > On 12/10/10, NJ/4th wrote: >> Any advice/tips on helping students check and correct their >> spelling while they're writing? I have about five days to >> do Writers Workshop and don't have enough time to check the >> spelling of 47 fourth graders. I need them to be able to do >> most of this on their own. How can students find their own >> mistakes when they don't even realize the word is misspelled >> in the first place? > > Well, they can't. I separate spelling out from writing > actually... Students can write even if they can't spell and > if they can't spell, it's better than it doesn't stop them > from writing. > For two reasons - their spelling usually improves with age - > why wait for that? Why have them write only when they can > spell? > > And - I rarely write anything by hand anymore - who does?? I > use Spellcheck and it tells me with a wavy red or green line > that I haven't spelled something correctly. > > I put up a word wall with commonly misspelled words and if I > have time, I'll circle misspelled words in their paper and > write the correctly spelled words above it. But - I require > my students of almost all ages to type.
I never get to actually watch the national spelling bee but I like finding out who won. For at least the last few years the winners have all been kids whose parents are from India. It's an interesting phenomenon and someone actually wrote an article about it - linked below.
On 6/03/11, Chan wrote: > I never get to actually watch the national spelling bee but > I like finding out who won. For at least the last few > years the winners have all been kids whose parents are from > India. It's an interesting phenomenon and someone actually > wrote an article about it - linked below. >