How do you motivate kids when the parents themselves aren't motivated? Had a whole classful of those this year... Needless to say, it wasn't a stellar year!
On 6/15/11, Terry wrote: > VET, > > That is a great suggestion and a procedure that I also use with my > seventh graders but something is different with these children > because they don't care (compared to when I started teaching 30 > years ago). I had some parents who cared more than there children > and this didn't help motivation. My students who were intrinsically > motivated succeeded and did well. The others failed and they are > not motivated to pass because they know that they won't be > retained. They have been placed every year. What the > administrators don't get is that the harm is to the student and > eventually it will catch up with them. > > Terry
>> That is a great suggestion and a procedure that I also use with my >> seventh graders but something is different with these children >> because they don't care (compared to when I started teaching 30 >> years ago). I had some parents who cared more than there children >> and this didn't help motivation. My students who were intrinsically >> motivated succeeded and did well. The others failed and they are >> not motivated to pass because they know that they won't be >> retained. They have been placed every year. What the >> administrators don't get is that the harm is to the student and >> eventually it will catch up with them. >> >> Terry
You may complete this assi...See MoreI have been teaching for many more years than some of you are old. I have yet to stubble on to the magic formula that does it. So obviously there is no one size fits all.
One thing I think helps is if they feel they have some ownership in their learning. One way to provide this is by giving them choices.
You may complete this assignment by either drawing a diagram that explains (whatever) or write a paragraph explaining it.
I found that by giving choices, the assignment becomes theirs - not mine. It is difficult to come up with choices for everything, however. I do love it when they come up with yet a third or fourth way to show me they understand.
Then be creative in finding ways to incorporate what they want into the cu...See MoreOn 6/20/11, Jamie wrote: > On 6/19/11, Lynnstarr wrote: Any more suggestions > for those that are such a struggle to motivate? Get to know the kids. Ask them "What motivates you?", "What are you interested in?" "If you could study anything, what would it be?"
Then be creative in finding ways to incorporate what they want into the curriculum... two examples follow. "I like skateboarding." one might say. Ok, that's physical education... but one can also look at the cost of building a skateboard from scratch, that's estimation and mathematics. One can look at the physics of learning a new trick - that's science. One can look at the history of skateboarding, when did it begin, who are the current leaders of skateboarding, who was a leader beforehand - have them do the research. One can examine skateboarding as a career, one can look at the related fields to skateboarding, fashion, music and so on.
"I like spongebob square pants." the cartoon. Ok, there is media studies, what impact has spongebob squarepants had on you? That reflective writing, English. How much money has the cartoon series created for the owners? Finance and maths again. How many people go into making a single episode of spongebob square pants? Estimation, research, careers. Has Spongebob square pants made an impact on our society, in what way? SOSE and writing. Describe 5 minutes of dialogue of the show, observation skills, writing and comprehension
I agree with you on the fact that giving student's choices in one way to motivate students because the student's feel that the assignment has become their own. Creating the opportunity for students to own an assignment makes the work more interesting for the students because they have the choice to make it that way. In addition, this strategy all adheres to the different types of learners and the way they remember information. Another strategy that I find helpful is allowing the students to use think-pair-share when completing assignments. Using think-pair-share allows students the opportunity think critically and make predictions or conclusions about specific topics. By giving students the chance to think about a topic in a way that does not force them to write, the teacher is giving them the a higher chance of remembering and learning the information.
Sure, sometimes this sense of accomplishment comes from getting the teacher to lose her temper or hitting a friend in the head with a well-aimed spitball. Our jobs, then, become refocusing that student’s goal away from those negative accomplishments towards the positive accomplishments – those that equate to success in school and, ideally, in life.
Sounds easy, right? You and I both know, though, that bad habits are hard to break, and students with a habit of looking for success in ways that undermine what we’re doing as teachers can often have the hardest time changing their habits.
janaOn 6/13/11, In Teachers.Net Gazette wrote: > Every child wants to succeed. I know this is true. If you > want to be successful at motivating the reluctant learner, > you will need to believe this as well. In my experience > working with students from many different backgrounds, > up-bringing, family situations and home lives, every s...See MoreOn 6/13/11, In Teachers.Net Gazette wrote: > Every child wants to succeed. I know this is true. If you > want to be successful at motivating the reluctant learner, > you will need to believe this as well. In my experience > working with students from many different backgrounds, > up-bringing, family situations and home lives, every student > thrives when he or she feels a sense of accomplishment. > > Sure, sometimes this sense of accomplishment comes from > getting the teacher to lose her temper or hitting a friend > in the head with a well-aimed spitball. Our jobs, then, > become refocusing that student’s goal away from those > negative accomplishments towards the positive > accomplishments – those that equate to success in school > and, ideally, in life. > > Sounds easy, right? You and I both know, though, that bad > habits are hard to break, and students with a habit of > looking for success in ways that undermine what we’re doing > as teachers can often have the hardest time changing their > habits. > > When I start a school year... I really enjoyed this article. I am going to write these tips down on a note card and tape to my desk to remind me of this idea. Thanks for sharing.
The next week I caught him putting some answers down on the study guides. He earned a B. This seemed to scare him and I stepped back. The next unit was a repeat of the Crucible - almost a C. For the next unit, I'd casually remark that it would be nice to see some better answers on his classwork, that I knew he had more to say about what Patrick Henry had to say than what Johnny wrote. He earned another B.
As I returned the tests, I mentioned he was 2 points shy of an A. That year, Johnny fluctuated: he'd get an A, then drop to a C. by the third quarter, he had confided that teachers had told him that English just wasn't his subject.
I had Johnny the following year for English 12. He was an A/B student. Johnny was doing well in his other classes also.
My point? Encourage, and don't be disheartened when they slide back. Those "fantastic" kids need time to adjust to a new vision of themselves.
I have to follow a pretty strict comprehensive curriculum and pacing guide, so there's not a lot of wiggle room to do projects and things not specified by the state. It's not like I can spend time discussing the history of basketball, reality TV, or violent movies.
I get very little parental support. I can't tell you the number of times parents never returned my call or calling a number that's no longer working.
I feel like a failure. I see Stand and Deliver, Freedom Writers, and Dangerous Minds and ask "why can't I do that?"
Why can't I get my students to want to acheive and do their best?
My students learn, and I do prepare them for the state tests, but I'm not motivating them!
I often feel more of a prison guard and test prep facilitator than an educator. I feel someone with a GEE, a copy of the state curriculum and pacing guide and the teacher's manual could do my job and all my education in history (21 hours of grad level history) is going to waste.
SteveOn 11/08/11, mpachank wrote: > On 11/08/11, Steve wrote: >> >>> >>> I can tell by talking to them that they're capable of making more >>> than a D-. I can tell by the books I see them reading for fun >>> (none of which ever have anything to do with history by the >>> way! :-( ) >> >>...See MoreOn 11/08/11, mpachank wrote: > On 11/08/11, Steve wrote: >> >>> >>> I can tell by talking to them that they're capable of making more >>> than a D-. I can tell by the books I see them reading for fun >>> (none of which ever have anything to do with history by the >>> way! :-( ) >> >> Well, that's very interesting. So these kids can read and do read for >> fun? Most kids don't read history books for fun but that they do read >> for fun is impressive - that's most often the sign of a stronger > student. >> >> So here's the question - how are they doing in their other classes? >> Are they D- students pretty much across the board or is their >> performance in history their only poor performance? > > > They're pretty much D or C students in their core courses. > Well, then, what you're asking is like this. It's like your spouse coughing all day long and then all night long too and you say - if I could only get to stop coughing at night, that would solve the problem.
No it wouldn't. It's not a nighttime problem even though it only bothers you when she comes home at night. There's an underlying problem causing the coughing.
These kids are doing poorly in all their classes - just this year or does it back in time? They're juniors - they've had two years of high school. It would be remarkable if it were just this year. I wish you well but you cannot turn around a steam locomotive coming right at you.
But what do your building colleagues say? I'd say it's rather like you're looking for a miracle. I have occasionally seen that but it takes some doing and doing things pretty differently. Did you ever see a film called Stand and Deliver? He met with those kids straight through the summer and that was not a required class - yours likely is. Or Dangerous Minds? But she too did things pretty differently. You can't cast the wide net over these kids unless you cast the net in a very different way and - there are no quick fixes. I'm sorry to say. >>>
On 6/15/11, Terry wrote: > VET, > > That is a great suggestion and a procedure that I also use with my > seventh graders but something is different with these children...See More