Prince George County Schools loses lawsuit.

Join Teachers.Net

Chatboards

Recent Groups

MD Teachers

MEMBERS

3 Members

+ Join Group

Pinned Posts

ALLAll Teachers

Teachers.Net LIVE CHAT Support group - Tues eve!

Featured Jobs

Full-timeMontessori Teacher

Maple Ridge, British Columbia, Canada

TemporaryTeachers, rural schools

Peace River North School District

Full-timeHead Teacher: 2nd/3rd Grades – Mills College Children’s School

Mills College

Teaching Jobs on Teachers.Net

Featured Job special only $39!

https://teachers.net/jobs

Become a Teachers.Net sponsor!

Maryland Teachers Chatboard

Prince George County Schools loses lawsuit.

by Pinoy teachers

Apr 11, 2011

So does anybody know what the outcome of this will be?

So far both Prince George County and Louisiana (New Orleans?) have been hit with lawsuits on behalf of the Philippino teachers that have en masse replaced American teachers in these districts. It is possible that Baltimore City Schools will also be sued.

What will be the outcome of these lawsuits as far as how these districts view hiring foreign teachers instead of Americans? Does anybody know the answer?

Also, with thousands of math teachers being drained from the Philippines, will there be a new generation of math teachers produced there since nobody qualified will be there to teach today's youth. What will happen in America if Americans begin to entirely avoid becoming math and science teachers since they will just be displaced by foreign workers anyway.

Any opinions on this matter?

Comment

(2)

report post

good questions I have no clue what will happen, but I worked in Baltimore City a few years ago and knew some Phillipino teachers. I do know that, even after all the sacrifices and expenses these teachers made to come to the U.S. the City did not hesitate to nonrenew them if they had difficulty managing the extrenmely challenging students. If school districts have...See More

Apr 13, 2011

report post

pinoy teachers On 4/13/11, good questions wrote: > I have no clue what will happen, but I worked in Baltimore > City a few years ago and knew some Phillipino teachers. I do > know that, even after all the sacrifices and expenses these > teachers made to come to the U.S. the City did not hesitate > to nonrenew them if they had difficulty managing th...See MoreOn 4/13/11, good questions wrote: > I have no clue what will happen, but I worked in Baltimore > City a few years ago and knew some Phillipino teachers. I do > know that, even after all the sacrifices and expenses these > teachers made to come to the U.S. the City did not hesitate > to nonrenew them if they had difficulty managing the > extrenmely challenging students.

I was wondering about that. So they are just as fast to nonrenew them as the American teachers?

If school districts have to > pay the full cost of these teachers to come here, maybe they > will se less need to import them, especially with such a > surplus of American teachers who need jobs. Teachers who need > a job are probably more willing to consider a tough school > district now.

I wondered about this. I thought about it and decided that they would probably still prefer to hire foreign teachers because they will be thinking that they will never have to pay them very much money because when they get higher on the pay ladder, they can just get rid of them. Whereas American teachers can earn tenure and eventually make higher incomes by moving up on the pay scale. With the foreign teachers, they can get rid of them when they start costing too much and they can control them more since they are more vulnerable to being sent back to their own country anytime they displease their overlord. I think American teachers have not much chance to compete against cheap labor and workers who must obey without question to the point of being abused maybe.

And the kids were not the mosts difficult part > of the job. It was the totally unsupportive and even hostile > administrators who treat you like crap in front of the > students.

Absolutely agree with you there. Been there, done that. Administrators can be very abusive. As they say, absolute power corrupts absolutely. The only bulwark against that corruption is tenured teachers. However, tenured teachers are going the way of the polar bear. More and more districts are finding clever ways to rid themselves of tenured teachers. This is especially true with urban schools/districts. Hiring H1B teachers is one way. Getting rid of teachers just before they achieve tenure is one way. Using long-term and short-term subs in the place of a regular teacher for the entire term or year is one way. Hiring teachers as leave replacements even though they are replacing a teacher who has permanently quit, etcetera, etcetera. Urban districts are increasingly staffed by very limited numbers of tenured teachers. This creates an atmosphere wherein it is very easy for the admin to trample on and even terrorize teachers.

The tenured teachers are a small minority and are generally left alone so they are content to allow this to happen to the transient, new teachers who they come to see as outsiders. It makes them feel special or superior knowing that they are there for many years whilst they watch so many get chewed up and spit out like meat going through a grinder. Often the tenured teachers begin to participate in the abuse. At best they passively watch it or ignore it. It is the type of thing you see happen in group psychology experiments where some participants are encouraged to administer punishment, pain, bullying or other abuse to other participants. The majority of participants who are given authority and power to abuse others and who are encouraged to do it by either direct instruction or by indirect modeling of the behavior do participate in the abuse. It is quite predictable and almost invariable behavior.

Apr 15, 2011

report post