HS English
MEMBERS
12 Members

Teaching Jobs on Teachers.Net

Start a new discussion...
I believe it's the fault of English teachers' way of teaching less v. fewer that is causing people to just use "less" all the time.

Here is my reasoning:

When I was in high school, English teachers seemed to make up their own definitions without regard to the dictionary. In the less v. fewer instance, they thought that saying one was for amounts and the other for quantity was sufficient to tell when to use less or fewer. The dictionaries I've read use amount to define quantity, and quantity to define amount. That makes them synonyms, which everyone knew anyway. This was a pretty useless endeavor, differentiating two terms using synonyms, and one of the terms fell out of use.

Lately, some teachers are saying "If you count it, use fewer." Brilliant idea. Too bad they didn't do that over the last fifty years.

You may now flame the retired science teacher.
Novel Not flaming but may I remind you that literacy is a cross- curricular concern
Aug 5, 2012
anon It's the easiest concept out there. Fewer=count, less=can't count

Examples: She has fewer cartons of milk than I have. (can count) I have less milk in my glass than she has. (can't count)

The two have NEVER been synonymous.

n 7/18/12, retired science teacher wrote: > I believe it's the fault of English teachers' way...See More
Aug 6, 2012
retired I did not say that fewer and less were synonyms. I said amount and quantity are synonyms. Seven out of the first eleven online dictionaries here [link removed].

My gripe is that English teachers have used two synonyms, amount and quantity, to try to tell the difference between less and fewer. The "count=fewer" thing is excellent, but recen...See More
Aug 18, 2012
Paula So...

I'm not the *only* one who gets annoyed by the "20 items or less" lines out there?

:
Aug 26, 2012


Teacher Chatboards

States

Subject Areas

Language Arts

Foreign Language